Mitchell (Geviert) – Heidegger’s consideration of inanimate or material nature

Heidegger’s consideration of inanimate or material nature is ultimately a destabilization of the very “materiality” of it. The stone is not brute matter, the stone speaks. The stone is the materialization of pain, of crossing, it is the hardness of what holds open the world. Water for its part interrupts the landscape with division, stretching the origin forth into encounters, offering what is most its own as welcome to what comes. In both cases we are confronted with a thinking of transition and relationality, whereby what exists does so by extending itself toward another. This is Heidegger’s response to those who would object that what he presents as true of stone or river is only applicable to the poetized stones of Trakl or the rivers of Hölderlin Hölderlin FRIEDRICH HÖLDERLIN (1770-1843). La poesía de Holderlin está sustentada por el destino y la determinación poética de poetizar propiamente la esencia de la poesía. Para nosotros, Holderlin es en sentido eminente el poeta del poeta. (GA39 p. 32) . Relationality is not a quality of objects. It is not something that can be observed by an otherwise untouched subject. It does not appear at a distance, it is closer than it appears. For there to be relationality, we must be relayed into it ourselves. The world appears relational to the poet who relates into it. In the 1934 course on Hölderlin Hölderlin FRIEDRICH HÖLDERLIN (1770-1843). La poesía de Holderlin está sustentada por el destino y la determinación poética de poetizar propiamente la esencia de la poesía. Para nosotros, Holderlin es en sentido eminente el poeta del poeta. (GA39 p. 32) this was expressed in terms of the historicality of a people: “River and poet both belong in their essence to the founding of the dwelling and Dasein of a historical people” (GA 39 GA39
GA 39
GA XXXIX
GA39ES
GA39FR
GA39EN Hölderlins Hymnen „Germanien“ und „Der Rhein“ (Wintersemester 1934/1935), ed. Susanne Ziegler, 1. Auflage 1980. 2., durchgesehene Auflage 1989. 3., unveränderte Auflage 1999 : 259–60). The 1942 “Ister” course is more direct: “When Hölderlin Hölderlin FRIEDRICH HÖLDERLIN (1770-1843). La poesía de Holderlin está sustentada por el destino y la determinación poética de poetizar propiamente la esencia de la poesía. Para nosotros, Holderlin es en sentido eminente el poeta del poeta. (GA39 p. 32) poetizes the essence of the poet, he poetizes relations that do not have their ground in the ‘subjectivity’ of human beings. These relations have their own prevailing, essencing, and flowing. The poet is the river. And the river is the poet” (GA 53 GA53
GA 53
GA LIII
SS 1942 Hölderlins Hymne "Der Ister" (SS 1942) [1984] : 203/165, tm, em). This is why the poet is not presenting symbols of an otherwise extant river or providing imaginative coloring for something otherwise actual. What the poet poetizes is that river, not a sign of it, as Heidegger never tires of repeating: “The rivers cannot be ‘poeticized images’ or ‘signs of’ something because they in themselves are ‘the signs,’ ‘signs’ that are no longer ‘signs’ of something else, nor symbols of something else, but are themselves this supposed ‘something else’” (GA 53 GA53
GA 53
GA LIII
SS 1942 Hölderlins Hymne "Der Ister" (SS 1942) [1984] : 204/166).

The poetic presentation of material nature is thus not an embellishment of what otherwise already exists. The poetic presentation allows the thing in question to show itself as relational and this means at the same time that it shows itself as participating in a world of sense. The metaphysical separation of the sensible from the super-sensible—“only within metaphysics is there the physical and the sensual in distinction from the non-physical and non-sensual. Metaphysics is precisely the reign of this difference” (GA 75 GA75
GA 75
GA LXXV Zu Hölderlin - Griechenlandreisen [2000] : 166)—no longer applies to the material nature of Heidegger’s fourfold. We shall have opportunity to return to this line of thought in our discussion of the thing and world (chapter six).